Wow. I really never do get these mysteries right. Always thinking things to be way more complicated than they are. But I did get my "Oh!" moment. Let's see:-
- Fantastic setup at the beginning of the season with the sociology class guard/prisoner experiment. I wondered why Wallace and Logan’s sociology class experiment was featured at all to begin with, and holy crap, it was the key to this mystery. That photo on the wall with Mercer and Moe in their uniforms, add a falling ceramic mug – that’s right my friends, there’s your Keyser Soze moment. (I’m sure the victim’s (and her sister’s name readily written on a cup) name is no coincidence here.) Hm, I wonder if Homer will get into trouble for administering these experiments that pretty much led to the rapes. Hey, at least I got the shaver/apist right; there were two people – a shaver and a rapist. But anyway, I really liked that it was the sociology experiment that spawned the rapist(s) Mercer and Moe. So simple. Occam’s Razor, right?
- I’m not sure how well the execution went though. There were a lot of holes in the mystery that we never got an answer to, and didn’t make too much sense. First, would have liked more backstory/flashbacks of Moe and Mercer, and how they ganged up on doing the rapes in the first place. Mercer’s little speech to himself in the (to be ) victim’s room didn’t make enough sense for me. So Mercer just doesn’t like to waste time with girls, and so he rapes? Huh? So was Mercer a rapist before the experiment too? And the shaving is kind of like prison (and their make believe experiment)? I’m at a loss here. Also, why did Moe keep the hair? Fetish? Weird prisoner present? This is the place for a really really good flashback that would explain all of this, and I was very disappointed they didn’t have one here.
-Hey, on the topic of flashbacks, did they just decide to replace them with Veronica’s drugged out vision? Flashbacks are way better. Plus, how many times does Veronica need to be drugged?
- Mercer’s alibi … is really not an alibi. That was annoying. I’m not even sure how it works – so was the radio show a live show or taped? Veronica realizes the radio show could be taped when she hears a glitch(?) at the party (not to mention seeing Mercer just moments earlier) – which means the show really isn’t live. But I thought the whole point of Moe was to provide for Mercer’s alibi – like when Parker was shaved, it was Moe and not Mercer – which means the show really IS live?
- Why put in an ad in the paper? Or was that really just the feminists trying to warn others?
- The freaking DNA/semen/hair evidence that didn’t exist in all the rapes – so DID Mercer raped these women or not? I didn’t think he was being especially careful with his hair (how funny would it be if he was all dressed up like Dexter here?) and/or anything else. From his rant, I’m assuming that Mercer did rape the girls, so why were his victims so clean? Also, he would never have gotten away with the rapes in this episode, even if he’d dosed Veronica with tons of drugs – his blood in the room and unicorn, his skin under Veronica’s nails, etc, etc. See, if he’s so sloppy this time, it makes me wonder how he was so meticulous previously to leave nothing.
- Nice Lucky Tim diversion. So he wasn’t investigating the rapes, he was investigating his girlfriend. Wasn’t it weird though he seemed excited for Veronica to meet the girlfriend? Like he’d set it all up or something. Weird.
- Oh how can I forget? “Ask me about my STD” Mac’s back. She didn’t really do anything pivotal here, but still loved that she at least was in the episode. Geez – Mac better get more screen time, that’s all I gotta say.
- Still not sure if I like Piz much, but that dance was quite remarkable. And avuncular. Also liked the Wallace and Piz tag team. Cute. Btw, why didn’t Veronica ask Piz to be backup when she was hiding out in the victim’s room waiting for Mercer? How about just a call to anyone?
- Ok, there’s no way Parker is still wearing a wig. Look at that hair! It was pretty nice of her to save Veronica. For a girl who’s so independent, she sure needs a lot of rescuing.
- LoVe: I was sad to see Logan break up with Veronica, but from previous episodes, it was a natural progression of their relationship. So heartbreaking, but quite necessary - it’ll be refreshing to see them together, but not together. Will Logan get his groove/snarkiness back? Let’s hope so. Really nice of him to beat the crap out of that police car in order to beat the crap out of Mercer. “You sick fuck, how dare you tried shaving my ex-girlfriend? And to think I went to Tijuana with you!” Gosh, I guess Logan really attracts trouble. His dad murdered Lilly, his friend’s brother bombed the bus, and now his new Hearst buddy is the rapist. He’s never going to get a break, huh?
- Pretty creepy for Weevil to find Dean O’Dell (presumably) dead in the office. And right when he’s hooking him up with HDTV. Darn it, I really liked Dean O’Dell here, and it sucks not to have him on the show anymore. So that’s why he got so much camera time this season without being part of this mystery. But this makes for a very solid setup for this second mystery, which should help with the timing and pace. Given he’s also Keith’s kind of friend, it’ll be nice to see Keith and Veronica working together to solve this next case.
Until then, good night…for now. Veronica Mars should be back in January. (Phew.)